TLDRs;
- Carvana stock dips 2.1% despite Wall Street raising price targets sharply.
- Analysts cite online sales growth and new-car expansion as long-term drivers.
- Broader tech selloffs and crowded trades weighed on Carvana’s short-term gains.
- Investors await mid-February earnings to see if momentum justifies high valuations.
Carvana Co. (CVNA) shares retreated Wednesday despite a flurry of bullish ratings from major Wall Street firms.
The used-car retailer closed at $458.61, down from intraday highs near $474, as some investors opted to lock in gains following a rapid rally in the stock. After-hours trading showed little movement, suggesting that the immediate market reaction to new price targets has stabilized.
The pullback comes amid a crowded trade environment for Carvana, which has seen extraordinary momentum over the past year. Analysts’ upgraded forecasts, while supportive, also set a high bar for upcoming earnings, raising questions about whether the company can meet heightened expectations.
Analysts See Growth Potential
Deutsche Bank led the upgrade parade, lifting its target to a Street-high $600 from $395 and maintaining a “Buy” rating. Analyst Lee Horowitz highlighted Carvana’s “physical moats” and the company’s strong positioning in the early-stage shift toward online vehicle sales as key drivers for future growth.
Other Wall Street firms also raised their outlooks. BofA Securities increased its target to $515, citing Carvana’s move into franchised new-car sales in regions including the Bay Area and Sacramento. UBS raised its target to $545 while keeping a “Buy” rating, reflecting confidence in Carvana’s continued market momentum.
Separately, Investor’s Business Daily upgraded the company’s proprietary Composite Rating to 96 from 94, a technical metric popular with growth-focused investors.
Market Forces Temper Gains
Despite these bullish signals, broader market trends played a role in Carvana’s decline. Technology and growth stocks faced pressure on Wednesday, reflecting profit-taking and cautious sentiment among investors. Even companies with strong individual fundamentals experienced minor pullbacks, illustrating how macro conditions can temporarily overshadow company-specific catalysts.
Carvana has emerged as one of the more volatile growth stocks in recent years. After weathering a 2022 squeeze in debt and demand, the company nearly doubled its stock price in 2025 and surged again after being added to the S&P 500 last month. However, the rapid growth also exposes the company to risks, including fluctuating used-car demand, tighter financing conditions, and operational challenges as it expands into new-car sales.
Eyes on Upcoming Earnings
All eyes now turn to Carvana’s upcoming earnings report, expected between February 18 and 23. The report will serve as a critical test of the company’s ability to meet elevated expectations and justify its bullish valuations. Analysts and investors alike are watching for sales trends, credit quality metrics, and execution in the company’s expanding new-car operations.
While the stock faces short-term volatility, the bullish narrative remains intact. Analysts see Carvana’s leadership in online auto retail as a long-term growth story, but near-term swings are likely as investors balance optimism with caution. For now, the stock’s performance highlights the challenges of navigating crowded trades in a market where expectations are rising faster than the fundamentals can immediately support.
Get 3 Free Stock Ebooks
Discover top-performing stocks in AI, Crypto, and Technology with expert analysis.
- Top 10 AI Stocks - Leading AI companies
- Top 10 Crypto Stocks - Blockchain leaders
- Top 10 Tech Stocks - Tech giants
